Why Oklahoma roof claims are being reviewed again
On November 13, 2026, the Oklahoma Insurance Department announced a settlement with State Farm Fire and Casualty Company valued at more than $45 million. It reopens eligible wind and hail roof claims with dates of loss from 2021 through 2025 that were denied, partly paid, or closed under the deductible, and an independent claims administrator will review the original file and any new evidence.1 Hundreds of homeowner lawsuits and a separate Attorney General case remain pending. Every one of those files will be read again, by someone. Read the full settlement analysis.
What the firm reviews
Estimate review and reconciliation
Line-by-line comparison of the carrier estimate, contractor estimates and any later estimate in Xactimate. Scope, quantities, pricing and price list dates, steep and high charges, code items, overhead and profit, depreciation, and the deductible, with each difference explained in plain terms.
Claim file review
Adjuster notes, inspection photographs, test square documentation, engineering reports, letters and payment history, read to answer one question: does the file support the outcome? Findings are delivered as a written summary or a formal report.
Litigation and appraisal document review
Petitions, claim file productions, discovery responses, opposing expert reports, deposition transcripts and appraisal awards. The review identifies what the record shows, what is missing, and where the adjusting practice was or was not consistent with industry standards.
Reinspection
Where the roof is still in place, a slope-by-slope reinspection with photo documentation of storm damage, wear, collateral damage and repairability.
Reviewer capacity for review programs
Licensed adjusters and file reviewers for claim administrators and adjusting firms staffing a review program in Oklahoma, supervised by a senior Executive General Adjuster.
Roles the firm accepts
- Consulting expert. Non-testifying file and estimate analysis, early case assessment and deposition preparation.
- Testifying expert. Written reports, deposition and trial testimony on scope, causation, valuation and claim handling. See expert witness services.
- Party appraiser or neutral umpire. Under the policy appraisal clause. See appraisal and umpire services.
- Independent reviewer. For claim administrators, adjusting firms and claim departments.
The firm accepts one role per matter, and every engagement starts with a conflict check against the parties, counsel of record and the carrier. Most conflict checks clear within two business days.
Qualifications
- Executive General Adjuster with more than 25 years of catastrophe and large loss property claims experience.
- Licensed Oklahoma adjuster.
- Xactimate estimating for 25 years.
- Thousands of claims handled, including hundreds of losses over $1 million.
- IICRC Water Damage Restoration and Applied Structural Drying certified.
A curriculum vitae, fee schedule and testimony list are available on request. See full credentials.
Common questions
Do you represent homeowners in the State Farm reopening process?
No. Okla Risk Advisors is not a public adjuster. In Oklahoma, a person who represents a policyholder’s interests on a claim for a fee must hold a public adjuster license unless an exception applies.2 Homeowners who want representation should contact a licensed public adjuster or an attorney. The firm can work with that attorney as a consultant or expert.
Can you review a file if the roof has already been replaced?
Yes. The review then relies on the original photographs, the inspection record, the estimates and the contractor’s replacement documentation.
How fast can a review start?
After the conflict check clears, most file reviews can begin within a few business days. Turnaround depends on the size of the file and the deadline schedule.
Do you work on claims with other insurers?
Yes. The same review applies to wind and hail roof claims with any carrier, in Oklahoma and in every other state.
Sources
- Okla. Ins. Dep’t, Mulready Announces More Than $45 Million in State Farm Settlement Following Extensive Roof Claims Investigation (Nov. 13, 2026). State agency release
- Okla. Stat. tit. 36, § 6202; see also § 6203. State statute
