Skip to main content
OKLA RISK ADVISORS 913-717-9128Request service

Insurance Appraiser and Umpire Services

Party-appointed insurance appraiser or neutral insurance umpire for property insurance appraisal on homes, commercial buildings and condominiums.

Party-appointed appraiserNeutral umpireCommercial and condominium
Asphalt shingle roof with widespread missing and creased shingles after a windstorm
Field inspection: wind-damaged shingle roof with missing and creased tabs.

Led by an Executive General Adjuster with more than 25 years of catastrophe and large loss experience.

Engagements
  • Party-appointed appraiser
  • Neutral umpire
  • Umpire by court appointment
  • Appraisal clause review

Appraisal that resolves the amount of loss

Appraisal resolves disputes over the amount of loss without litigation. Each side appoints a competent and independent appraiser, the appraisers select an umpire, and an award signed by any two sets the amount. Appraisal generally decides how much, not whether a loss is covered; coverage questions stay with the parties and, if necessary, the courts. The firm’s guide explains how the appraisal clause works.

Umpire rules differ by state. The firm’s 2026 guide covers umpire rules and court rulings in eight states, with a one-page state chart (PDF).

The firm serves as an independent appraiser for either party and as a neutral umpire by agreement of the appraisers or by court appointment. It accepts one role per matter, discloses anything bearing on impartiality up front, and runs conflict checks before any substantive discussion. Experience includes Gulf Coast high-rise condominium complexes with up to approximately $85 million in estimated damage.

Appraisal at a glance
RolesAppraiser or umpire
DesignationExecutive General Adjuster
Experience25+ years P&C catastrophe
Largest engagement~$85M high-rise envelope
Fee basisHourly or flat, never tied to the award
Conflict checkWithin two business days
RuleOne role per matter
Services

Appraisal and umpire services

01

Party-appointed appraiser

Independent appraiser for the insurer or the insured, separately stating actual cash value, replacement cost and the amount of loss and working the panel toward an award.

02

Neutral umpire

An impartial appraisal umpire when the appraisers cannot agree. Scope, causation and value are decided on the evidence.

03

Umpire by court appointment

Service when a court appoints the umpire under the policy or state procedure.

04

Appraisal readiness review

Pre-appraisal review of the estimate and documentation so the scope that goes to the panel holds up.

05

Commercial and condominium appraisal

Multi-building, association and commercial losses with business interruption and common-element questions.

06

Hurricane, hail and roof appraisal

Hail appraisal and roof appraisal disputes, plus cladding, water intrusion and wind versus water after storms.

How it works

The insurance appraisal process

STEP 1

Conflict check

Caption, parties, counsel and carrier cleared first.

STEP 2

Engagement

Role, fee schedule and disclosures confirmed in writing.

STEP 3

Inspection

Joint or independent inspection and document review.

STEP 4

Panel

Negotiation with the other appraiser, or umpire review.

STEP 5

Award

Itemized appraisal award signed by two of three.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Will the firm serve as appraiser for a policyholder?

Yes, as an independent party-appointed appraiser. Appraisers under most policies must be competent and independent, so the firm serves as an appraiser, not as a public adjuster or advocate.

Does the firm serve as umpire?

Yes, by agreement of the two appraisers or by court appointment, with disclosure of anything bearing on impartiality made before acceptance.

Can the firm be both appraiser and expert on the same matter?

No. The firm accepts one role per matter.

Where does the firm serve?

Nationwide, subject to state licensing or qualification rules for appraisers and umpires. See coverage by state.

What does appraisal decide?

Generally the amount of loss. Coverage questions are usually outside the panel’s authority and remain with the parties and the courts.

Need an appraiser or an umpire?

Send the caption or claim number, the parties, the carrier and the role you need. Conflict checks are cleared within two business days.