Skip to main content
OKLA RISK ADVISORS 913-717-9128Request service
Oklahoma roof claims

The State Farm Oklahoma Roof Claim Settlement: Who Qualifies, How Reopening Works, and What a Second Review Will Look For

The Oklahoma Insurance Department’s market conduct examination ended in a settlement of more than $45 million and a process to reopen wind and hail roof claims from 2021 through 2025. What is known, what is still pending, and how a claim file will be judged the second time.

Hail impacts across a roof surface documented during a field inspection
Field inspection: hail impacts on a roof surface.

In brief. On November 13, 2026, the Oklahoma Insurance Department (OID) released its market conduct examination of State Farm Fire and Casualty Company and announced a settlement valued at more than $45 million. Wind and hail roof claims with a date of loss from January 1, 2021, through December 31, 2025, that were closed without payment, including partial payments and claims found to be under the deductible, can be reopened at State Farm’s expense and reviewed by an independent third-party claims administrator. Deadlines, the opt-in method and the administrator’s name have not been announced. The settlement does not resolve the pending lawsuits.1,3

Last updated November 16, 2026. This article will be updated when OID publishes the opt-in deadlines and names the claims administrator.

Oklahoma has been the center of the national fight over hail claims for more than a year. Hundreds of homeowner lawsuits, a separate suit by the Attorney General and a Supreme Court of Oklahoma ruling on who may bring which claims have kept the issue in the news. On November 13, 2026, the state’s insurance regulator added a different kind of remedy: an administrative settlement that gives eligible homeowners a second review of their roof claims without filing suit.

For homeowners, the question is whether they qualify and what to do before the notice arrives. For attorneys, claim administrators and adjusting firms, the question is practical. Tens of thousands of roof claims may be eligible for review, and every one of them will be decided on the strength of the original claim file and whatever new evidence is added to it. This article covers what the settlement provides, what is still unknown, and what a second review of a roof claim file is likely to examine.

What the examination found and what the settlement provides

In its examination report and release (state agency findings), OID concluded that State Farm improperly denied or failed to pay for roof damage and necessary repairs on Oklahoma homeowners’ wind and hail claims. Commissioner Glen Mulready said the department did not rely on the company’s own account of how claims were handled and instead sent independent engineers into the field to inspect roofs.1

The settlement has four parts:

  • At least $35 million for consumer restitution, committed toward making affected policyholders whole.
  • $10 million to the Strengthen Oklahoma Homes program, which helps eligible homeowners install fortified roofs.
  • $2.86 million in fines and examination expenses paid to OID.
  • A claim reopening process run at State Farm’s expense.1

State Farm disagrees with the department’s findings and characterizations. It has said the resolution has no bearing on the pending litigation, that the report does not change customer policies or coverage, and that it has paid more than $2 billion for Oklahoma wind and hail damage since 2024.3 The exam findings are the regulator’s conclusions. They are not a court judgment on any individual claim.

Who is eligible for a reopened claim

Based on OID’s announcement, a claim is eligible when all of the following are true:

  • It was a State Farm homeowner’s claim for wind or hail damage to the roof.
  • The date of loss falls between January 1, 2021, and December 31, 2025.
  • The claim was closed without payment. OID includes partial payments and claims determined to be under the deductible in that category.1,2

The scale is significant. State Farm is Oklahoma’s largest homeowners insurer, with more than 30 percent of the market and more than 258,000 homeowners customers.4 The company has said it responded to more than 100,000 Oklahoma claims over five years.3 Not all of those were roof claims or closed without payment, but the eligible group is likely to run well into the thousands.

Need an Oklahoma roof claim file reviewed? See the roof claim review service, or contact the firm. Call 913-717-9128. We respond within two business days.

How the reopening process will work

State Farm will send written notices, approved by OID, explaining eligibility and how to opt in. Homeowners must opt in to be reviewed. An independent third-party claims administrator, chosen jointly by OID and State Farm, will review each eligible claim. The administrator will look at the original claim file and any additional documents or evidence the policyholder submits. A claim that qualifies will be paid under the terms of the individual policy, and if the restitution fund runs short, OID and State Farm will agree on an additional amount.1,2

Two features matter most in practice. First, the review is a file review: the outcome turns on what is in the original file and what the homeowner adds to it. Second, payment follows the policy. Deductibles, roof payment schedules, actual cash value and replacement cost holdback provisions still apply.

What has not been announced yet

OID has said eligibility details, timelines and the review process will be released as they are finalized.1 As of this writing, the following are still open:

  • The opt-in deadline and how to submit the opt-in.
  • The name of the claims administrator.
  • Whether the administrator will reinspect roofs or decide on documents alone.
  • What format additional evidence must take, and whether a contractor or adjuster estimate will be considered.
  • How a reopened claim interacts with appraisal rights under the policy and with any pending lawsuit.

The transition at OID adds some uncertainty. Incoming Insurance Commissioner Bob Sullivan said he was still learning the details and was concerned the settlement could reduce flexibility for regulatory action during his term.4

How the settlement relates to the lawsuits

OID describes the settlement as a completely separate action from both the homeowner lawsuits and the Attorney General’s case. The department also says its examination report can be used as prima facie evidence in other legal actions.3 That point is likely to matter in pending cases, because experts on both sides will compare individual claim files against the exam’s findings.

The litigation runs on three tracks:

  • Homeowner suits. The lead case, Hursh v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co., No. CJ-2025-2626, was filed in Oklahoma County District Court (state trial court) in April 2025.7 Many similar suits have followed. These are allegations, and the insurer denies wrongdoing.
  • The Supreme Court’s June 2026 ruling. In State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. v. Palumbo, 2026 OK 51, the Supreme Court of Oklahoma (state supreme court) issued a writ of prohibition that barred the Attorney General from intervening in Hursh. The Court held that his statutory claims would enlarge a private contract dispute, and noted he could pursue them in a separate proceeding.5
  • The Attorney General’s own suit. The State filed Oklahoma ex rel. Drummond v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co., No. CJ-2026-1066, in Cleveland County District Court (state trial court) on June 24, 2026, under the Oklahoma Consumer Protection Act and the Oklahoma Corrupt Organizations Prevention Act.6,3 The Attorney General has said that case will continue.8

What a second review of a roof claim file will look for

Whether the reviewer is the settlement administrator, an appraisal panel, or an expert in litigation, a roof claim is reconstructed from the same records. After more than 25 years of adjusting and reviewing hail claims, these are the points where files most often succeed or fail on review:

  • The inspection record. Whether each slope was inspected, whether test squares were laid out and counted, and whether the photographs show scale, direction and location. A file that says “no hail damage” without slope-by-slope documentation is hard to defend in either direction.
  • Damage versus wear. How the file separated storm damage from granule loss, blistering, thermal cracking and age. This is the core dispute in most Oklahoma hail claims.
  • Collateral indicators. Damage to soft metals, vents, gutters, siding and screens, and whether it was recorded and dated.
  • Date of loss. Whether the assigned date matches storm data for the address, and whether more than one storm hit the same roof during the policy period.
  • Repairability. Whether a repair was feasible given shingle condition, availability of a matching product and the manufacturer’s installation requirements.
  • The estimate itself. Line items for tear-off, underlayment, starter, ridge, drip edge, flashing, steep and high charges, code items, and contractor overhead and profit, along with the price list date used.
  • Payment math. How depreciation, the deductible and any roof payment schedule were applied, and whether replacement cost holdback was explained.
  • Engineering reports. What the engineer was asked to evaluate, what was inspected, and whether the conclusions match the photographs.

Most of this can be tested from the file without a new inspection. Where the roof has since been replaced, the original photographs and any contractor documentation become the only record.

For homeowners: what to do now

Watch for the written notice from State Farm and read it closely when it arrives. Commissioner Mulready’s advice to homeowners was not to assume the original decision was the final word.2 While waiting, gather what you have: the policy declarations page, the claim number, every letter and estimate from the insurer, your own photographs with dates, contractor estimates and invoices, and records of any repairs or roof replacement.

If you want someone to represent you, Oklahoma law matters. Under the Insurance Adjusters Licensing Act (state statute), a person or firm that represents a policyholder’s interests on a property claim for a fee must be licensed as a public adjuster, unless an exception applies, such as an Oklahoma attorney acting incidental to the practice of law.9,11 In a roofing contractor bulletin (state agency bulletin), OID has also told roofing contractors that they need a public adjuster license to represent a homeowner on a claim.10 Questions about the settlement can go to OID at 800-522-0071.2

For counsel, administrators and claim professionals

The reopening process and the pending litigation create the same workload: a large number of closed roof files that must be read, priced and compared against the policy and the exam findings. That work falls into a few categories:

  • Estimate review and reconciliation. Line-by-line comparison of the original estimate, the contractor estimate and any later estimate, with the pricing differences explained.
  • Claim file review. Reading adjuster notes, photographs, engineer reports and letters to determine whether the file supports the outcome.
  • Litigation document review. Petitions, claim file productions, discovery responses, expert reports and deposition transcripts, read by someone who has written and supervised this kind of file.
  • Reviewer capacity. Licensed adjusters and reviewers for administrators and adjusting firms that need to staff a review program in Oklahoma.

Because the exam report can serve as prima facie evidence, an independent read of a specific file, measured against the policy and accepted adjusting practice, is often what separates a strong case from a weak one, for either side.

Common questions

Do I have to file a lawsuit to get my State Farm roof claim reviewed?

No. The OID settlement creates a separate reopening process. Eligible homeowners opt in after receiving a written notice and are reviewed by an independent claims administrator.

My claim was paid, but only partly. Am I eligible?

OID says “closed without payment” includes partial payments and claims determined to be under the deductible. The final eligibility terms have not been published, so confirm when the notice arrives.

Does the settlement end the lawsuits against State Farm?

No. OID describes it as separate from the homeowner suits and the Attorney General’s case, and State Farm says it has no bearing on the litigation.

Can I add new evidence?

Yes. The administrator will review the original file and any additional documents or evidence the policyholder submits. What format is accepted has not been announced.

What if my roof has already been replaced?

The review will then depend on the original photographs, the insurer’s inspection record and any contractor documentation from the replacement. Keep invoices and photographs.

How ORA can help

Okla Risk Advisors is not a public adjuster and does not represent homeowners in the reopening process. The firm provides independent estimate, claim file and litigation document review for counsel on either side, claim administrators and adjusting firms, along with expert witness and appraiser and umpire services. Every engagement starts with a conflict check, and the firm accepts one role per matter. See also the Oklahoma appraisal and expert witness guide.

Sources

  1. Okla. Ins. Dep’t, Mulready Announces More Than $45 Million in State Farm Settlement Following Extensive Roof Claims Investigation (Nov. 13, 2026). State agency release
  2. News 9, Oklahoma reaches $45M settlement with State Farm over roof claims (Nov. 2026). News report
  3. Tulsa World via InsuranceNewsNet, State Farm policyholders may get new chance at payments on denied roof claims (Nov. 2026). News report
  4. Oklahoma Voice, State Farm to pay $45M after Oklahoma insurance investigation (Nov. 16, 2026). News report
  5. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Palumbo, 2026 OK 51, 593 P.3d 104 (Okla. June 23, 2026). State supreme court
  6. Oklahoma ex rel. Drummond v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. CJ-2026-1066 (Okla. Dist. Ct. Cleveland Cnty., filed June 24, 2026), as cited in Property Insurance Coverage Law Blog. State trial court
  7. Hursh v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co., No. CJ-2025-2626 (Okla. Dist. Ct. Okla. Cnty., filed Apr. 17, 2025), as described in the petition for writ of prohibition. State trial court
  8. KFOR via InsuranceNewsNet, State Farm settles for more than $45 million following investigation into Oklahoma roof damage claims (Nov. 2026). News report
  9. Okla. Stat. tit. 36, § 6202 (definitions, Insurance Adjusters Licensing Act). State statute
  10. Okla. Ins. Dep’t, Roofing Contractor Bulletin. State agency bulletin
  11. Okla. Stat. tit. 36, § 6203 (persons not deemed adjusters). State statute

Need an Oklahoma roof claim file reviewed?

Send the case caption or claim details and the deadline. You will get a conflict check within two business days, before any substantive discussion.