Skip to main content
OKLA RISK ADVISORS 913-717-9128Request service

Property Insurance Umpire, Appraisal and Expert Witness Services in Colorado

Colorado's hail and wildfire exposure, from Denver and the Front Range to the Western Slope, produces a steady first-party property docket. Expert witness retention, appraisal and umpire service, and ADR support. Every engagement is led by a senior Executive General Adjuster.

The firm also deploys catastrophe, large loss and NFIP flood adjusters to Colorado for carrier, TPA and adjusting firm surge capacity, and is available in every other state as well. See nationwide coverage and adjuster staffing.

Catastrophe and surge deploymentExecutive General Adjuster25+ years catastropheParty appraiser and umpireConflict checkedTwo-day conflict check
Close view of hail impact marks on metal roof shingles
Field inspection: documenting hail impacts slope by slope.

What drives Colorado property disputes

Typical loss types. Large hail along the Front Range, high wind, wildfire and post fire debris flow, and winter storm.

Colorado hail disputes turn on roofing system damage assessment, functional versus cosmetic damage, matching and slope replacement, and how depreciation and code requirements were applied. Wildfire matters add smoke, char, and contents questions along with total loss and additional living expense issues. Appraisal is used frequently to resolve amount of loss.

The firm holds IICRC Water Damage Restoration and Applied Structural Drying certifications, which support scope and causation analysis on the water and smoke components of these losses.

Colorado appraisal and umpire law

Who may serve. The Colorado Division of Insurance (state agency bulletin, Bulletin B-5.26) takes the position that appraisers must be fair and competent and that an umpire must be fair, competent and impartial. Under the bulletin, the umpire may not have an existing direct or material relationship with any party and must disclose facts a reasonable person would consider likely to affect impartiality. Insurers, insureds and their representatives must follow the policy language when selecting an appraiser or umpire. Bulletin B-5.26.

Impartial appraisers. In Owners Insurance Co. v. Dakota Station II Condominium Ass’n, 2019 CO 65 (state supreme court), the Supreme Court of Colorado read a policy requiring “impartial” appraisers to mean that party-appointed appraisers may not advocate for either side and must be unbiased and disinterested, although they need not meet the same standard as arbitrators. Summary of the decision.

Delay and denial remedies. Under C.R.S. §§ 10-3-1115 and 10-3-1116 (state statute), a first-party claimant whose covered benefit was unreasonably delayed or denied may recover two times the covered benefit plus reasonable attorney fees and court costs. Conduct during appraisal can be part of that analysis, which is one reason an appraisal record and award need to be clean. C.R.S. § 10-3-1116.

Pending reform. House Bill 26-1247 (state bill) would have required an appraisal clause in Colorado homeowner’s policies, split umpire costs between the parties, and set a four-month deadline after umpire selection. The House Business Affairs and Labor Committee postponed it indefinitely on March 25, 2026, so as of this update the bulletin and the policy language control. HB26-1247.

Compare Colorado with seven other states in umpire rules by state, or see appraiser and umpire services.

Roles the firm accepts in Colorado

  • Testifying expert. Written reports meeting the applicable disclosure rules, deposition, and trial testimony on scope, causation, valuation, estimating methodology, and claims handling and bad faith standards.
  • Consulting expert. Non testifying analysis, early case assessment, estimate reconstruction, and support for examination of the opposing expert.
  • Party-appointed appraiser. Competent and independent appraiser under the policy appraisal clause, separately stating actual cash value, replacement cost, and the amount of loss.
  • Neutral umpire. By agreement of the appraisers or by court appointment, with disclosure of anything bearing on impartiality made up front.
  • Mediation and arbitration support. Loss facts and scope gaps translated into a clear technical position and a damages narrative for the proceeding.

How to retain the firm

Send the caption, the parties, counsel of record, the carrier, the role you are seeking to fill, and the deadline schedule including expert disclosure and discovery cutoffs. Most conflict checks clear within two business days, before any substantive discussion of the matter. A curriculum vitae, fee schedule, and testimony list follow on request.

Availability is subject to conflict clearance and to any licensure, registration, or appointment requirement of the jurisdiction and the policy at issue. The firm accepts one role per matter.

Colorado engagement
StateColorado (CO)
Testifying expertAccepted
Consulting expertAccepted
Party appraiserAccepted
Neutral umpireAccepted
Mediation and arbitrationAccepted
Available toPolicyholder and insurer counsel
Conflict checkWithin two business days

Colorado appraisal rules

Other states

How appraisal works

The panel, and the line it cannot cross

Appraisal is a valuation mechanism. It binds as to the amount of loss, and it stops short of coverage. Knowing where that line sits is most of the work.

How an appraisal panel is formed and what it decidesEach party names a competent and impartial appraiser. The two appraisers select an umpire, or a court appoints one. The panel inspects, exchanges scopes and narrows differences, then states the amount of loss. An agreement of any two of the three sets the amount. Appraisal decides the amount of loss but does not decide coverage, conditions precedent, exclusions or bad faith, which are questions for the court. THE APPRAISAL PANEL Insured’s appraiser Competent and impartial, party appointed Carrier’s appraiser Competent and impartial, party appointed Umpire Selected by the appraisers, or by a court Award Any two of the three signatures set the amount The panel decides Amount of loss, actual cash value, replacement cost, scope quantities, and where relevant allocation between causes The panel does not decide Whether a peril is covered, whether a condition precedent was met, whether an exclusion applies, or bad faith. Those are for the court.

The firm accepts one role per matter. A party-appointed appraiser in a dispute cannot also be the retained testifying expert in it. Full explanation of the appraisal clause

Qualifications

Why counsel retains this firm

A curriculum vitae, fee schedule, and testimony list are furnished on request.

  • Executive General AdjusterThe senior adjusting designation, signifying authority over the largest and most complex property losses.
  • More than 25 years in catastrophe and large loss claimsField, large loss, and supervisory experience across national property and casualty carriers and in independent practice, with multi-line supervisory and catastrophe special-claims authority.
  • Documented large loss recordGulf Coast high-rise condominium assessments, the largest with approximately $85 million in estimated damage, drawn from thousands of claims handled.
  • NFIP certified at all four authority levelsRCBAP, commercial, homeowners, and mobile home.
  • Independent opinionsExpert witness, party-appointed appraiser and neutral umpire engagements, each accepted after a conflict check. Opinions follow the facts and the policy language.
Common questions

Retaining the firm in Colorado

What kinds of Colorado property disputes does the firm take?

First-party commercial and residential property matters, most often involving hail and roofing losses, wildfire, and wind driven water. The questions are usually scope of repair, whether damage is storm created or the result of age and wear, valuation and depreciation methodology, code and ordinance requirements, and claims handling standards.

Can the firm serve as a neutral umpire in Colorado?

Yes, by agreement of the two party-appointed appraisers or by court appointment. Anything bearing on impartiality is disclosed up front, before appointment. The firm also serves as a party-appointed appraiser where it has not been engaged as a neutral in the same matter.

How is a conflict check handled?

Every engagement starts with a conflict check against the parties, counsel of record and the carrier. Most checks clear within two business days. Opinions follow the facts and the policy language.

Is the firm licensed in Colorado?

Availability is subject to any licensure, registration or appointment requirement of the jurisdiction and the policy at issue. The firm holds multi-state property and casualty adjuster licensure with reciprocal deployment, and engagement is always subject to conflict clearance and to the requirements of the jurisdiction and the policy at issue. See coverage by state.

How long does a conflict check take?

Within two business days. Send the caption, the parties, counsel of record, the carrier, the role you are seeking to fill, and the deadline schedule. The conflict check runs before any substantive discussion of the matter, and a curriculum vitae, fee schedule and testimony list follow on request.

Retain the firm in Colorado.

Send the caption, the parties, counsel of record, and the carrier. Conflict checks usually clear within two business days, and the CV and fee schedule follow immediately.